Professor emérito de politica ciência de Yale
Robert Dahl faleceu aos 98 anos na última semana. Dahl é considerado um dos teóricos da democracia mais importantes do século XX. Sua obra
Poliarquia (traduzida pela EDUSP) causou uma pequena revolução nos estudos empíricos dos regimes democráticos - ou "poliárquicos" na linguagem de Dahl. Regimes democráticos não seriam definidos pelo governo do "povo", mas sim pelo processo de competição eleitoral (e contestação pública) entre diferentes grupos políticos. Além disso Dahl ofereceu uma das defesas mais influentes da democracia em
A Democracia e Seus Críticos (publicado pela Martins Fontes). Veja abaixo os obituários do NY Times e do Washington Post.
Robert Dahl
Robert A. Dahl Dies at 98; Yale Scholar Defined Politics and Power
Robert A. Dahl, a political scientist who was widely regarded as his profession’s most distinguished student of democratic government, died on Wednesday in Hamden, Conn. He was 98.
His stepdaughter Sara Connor confirmed the death.
In 2002, The New Yorker said Professor Dahl was “about as covered with honors as a scholar can be” and quoted the Cornell scholar Theodore J. Lowi as calling him “the foremost political theorist of this generation.”
Professor Dahl, who taught at Yale for 40 years, provided a definition of power that became a standard: “A has power over B to the extent that he can get B to do something that B would not otherwise do.”
In two dozen books and hundreds of articles, Professor Dahl wrote about foreign policy, Congress, welfare, the Constitution and more. He was an early proponent of using real-world data and empirical analysis in the study of politics, but did not shrink from making judgments on large issues.
“Over decades when political scientists focused on increasingly narrow and often technical questions, he’s the one person who brought everybody back to the big picture, the big questions,” James S. Fishkin, a professor of communications and political science at Stanford, said in an interview on Friday. “What is the form of democracy that will live up to democratic aspirations?”
Perhaps Professor Dahl’s best-known work was one of his earliest: “Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City” (1961), which examined the political workings of New Haven. In contrast to the view that power in American society was concentrated in a business elite, he depicted a multitude of groups competing for influence. “Instead of a single center of sovereign power,” he wrote, “there must be multiple centers of power, none of which is or can be wholly sovereign.”
New Haven, he argued, had experienced a historical progression from patrician rule to a more contested form of government in which political parties and candidates of different ethnic and economic backgrounds competed.
Professor Dahl initially defended pluralistic competition as inherently democratic, but in later books he theorized that powerful, politically agile minorities could thwart the will of other minorities and, indeed, majorities. He particularly worried that corporate managers could dictate the direction of their companies, often without reference to shareholders. He advocated giving outsiders, including government and interest groups like consumer representatives, a greater role in corporate governance.
He also wrote that citizens in recent years have had less influence over the political process, even as they have demanded more of it. He pointed to growing economic inequality as a threat to the political process. And he criticized the Constitution as undemocratic, saying it disregarded population differences in guaranteeing at least one representative and only two senators to each state.
Professor Dahl saw no way of changing this, because the Constitution specifically prohibits it. But he suggested reforms, like term limits for senators and representatives and runoff elections so that the winner of every race could claim a majority.
“He punctured our smug self-satisfaction that what we have is so great,” Professor Fishkin said.
Robert Alan Dahl was born on Dec. 17, 1915, in Inwood, Iowa, where his father was a doctor. When hard times made it impossible for many patients to pay their medical bills, the family moved to Skagway, Alaska, where a railroad had advertised for a doctor. Robert worked on the railroad and as a longshoreman during the summers and became a socialist and union advocate. The experience helped inspire him to study the effects of political power on average people.
He attended the University of Washington because it was the closest university, then accepted a fellowship to do graduate work in political science at Yale. After earning his Ph.D., he worked for the Agriculture Department and two agencies handling wartime industrial production. He then relinquished his draft deferment and joined the Army as an infantryman. He fought in Europe and earned the Bronze Star with oak cluster.
After the war ended, he was assigned to an Army unit charged with “de-Nazifying” the German banking system. Not wanting to go back to being a bureaucrat, he returned to Yale, got a temporary job there and ended up staying until 1986, when he retired as the Sterling professor of political science and senior research scientist in sociology.
Professor Dahl was chairman of the political science department from 1957 to 1962. In 1968, he led a committee that recommended that Yale become one of the first American universities to establish an undergraduate major in African-American culture. It did. In 1972, he headed a committee that recommended that Yale’s four-year course of study be cut to three and that majors be abolished. Those proposals were rejected.
Professor Dahl was president of the American Political Science Association in 1967. He was a member of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Philosophical Society and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. He was a Guggenheim Fellow twice. In 1995, he was the first recipient of the Johan Skytte Prize in Political Science, an award given by Uppsala University in Sweden to the scholar who has made the most valuable contribution to political science.
Professor Dahl’s first wife, the former Mary Bartlett, died in 1970. In addition to Ms. Connor, his stepdaughter, he is survived by his wife, the former Ann Sale; his daughter, Kirsten Dahl; another stepdaughter, Jane Thery; his sons, Eric and Christopher; and four grandchildren. Another son, Peter, died before him.
Professor Dahl readily conceded that most people are more interested in work, family, health, friendship and recreation than they are in politics, much less political science. “Politics is a sideshow in the great circus of life,” he wrote.
Correction: February 12, 2014
An obituary on Saturday about the political scientist Robert A. Dahl referred incorrectly to two of his survivors and misspelled the given name of one of them. Sara (not Sarah) Connor and Jane Thery are his stepdaughters, not his daughters. The obituary also mistakenly credited a concept to Professor Dahl. The political scientist David Easton — not Professor Dahl — wrote that politics involves “the authoritative allocation of values.”
