Saiu pela Oxford Press uma coletânea de artigos dedicados ao legado de Ronald Dworkin: The Legacy of Ronald Dworkin. A maior parte das contribuições, como tem sido recorrente no debate atual da filosofia do direito, centra sua atenção na última formulação de suas ideias, publicada em Justice for Hedgehogs de 2013 - fato tende a agradar realistas em relação à valores morais. A teoria da unidade dos valores desenvolvidas por Dworkin nessa obra o objeto do artigo do neopositivista Joseph Raz, talvez seja uma das grandes reformulações realistas (sobre valores morais) no debate contemporâneo e, enquanto tal, encontra-se em clara oposição a outras formulações liberais tal como, por exemplo, a de John Rawls. Parte dos capítulos do livro já circulavam em versões preliminares (agradeço ao blog Political Theory pelos links)
Em 2014, o grupo de teoria política da USP organizou um simpósio sobre as diferentes contribuições de Dworkin para a teoria política, filosofia do direito e metaética. Alguns dos working papers podem ser encontrados no site do evento. O evento foi uma resposta à presença constante das teorias de Dworkin (gostemos ou não delas) em nossos departamentos de filosofia e teoria política.
This book assembles leading legal, political, and moral philosophers to examine the legacy of the work of Ronald Dworkin. They provide the most comprehensive critical treatment of Dworkin's accomplishments focusing on his work in all branches of philosophy, including his theory of value, political philosophy, philosophy of international law, and legal philosophy.
The book's organizing principle and theme reflect Dworkin's self-conception as a builder of a unified theory of value, and the broad outlines of his system can be found throughout the book. The first section addresses the most abstract and general aspect of Dworkin's work—the unity of value thesis. The second section explores Dworkin's contributions to political philosophy, and discusses a number of political concepts including authority, civil disobedience, the legitimacy of states and the international legal system, distributive justice, collective responsibility, and Dworkin's master value of dignity and the associated values of equal concern and respect. The third section addresses various aspects of Dworkin's general theory of law. The fourth and final section comprises accounts of the structure and defining values of discrete areas of law.
The book's organizing principle and theme reflect Dworkin's self-conception as a builder of a unified theory of value, and the broad outlines of his system can be found throughout the book. The first section addresses the most abstract and general aspect of Dworkin's work—the unity of value thesis. The second section explores Dworkin's contributions to political philosophy, and discusses a number of political concepts including authority, civil disobedience, the legitimacy of states and the international legal system, distributive justice, collective responsibility, and Dworkin's master value of dignity and the associated values of equal concern and respect. The third section addresses various aspects of Dworkin's general theory of law. The fourth and final section comprises accounts of the structure and defining values of discrete areas of law.
Part I: The Unity of Value
1. A Hedgehog's Unity of Value - Joseph Raz
Part II: Political Values: Legitimacy, Authority, and Collective Responsibility
2. Political Resistance for Hedgehogs - Candice Delmas
3. Ronald Dworkin, State Consent and Progressive Cosmopolitanism - Thomas Christiano
4. To Fill or Not To Fill Individual Responsibility Gaps? - François Tanguay-Renaud
5. Inheritance and Hypothetical Insurance - Daniel Halliday
Part III: General Jurisprudence: Contesting the Unity of Law and Value
6. Putting Law in Its Place - Lawrence G. Sager
7. Dworkin and Unjust Law - David Dyzenhaus
8. The Grounds of Law - Luís Duarte d'Almeida
9. Immodesty in Dworkin's 'Third' Theory - Kenneth Einar Himma
10. Imperialism and Importance in Dworkin's Jurisprudence - Michael Giudice
11. A Theory of Legal Obligation - Christopher Essert
Part IV: Value in Law
12. Originalism and Constructive Interpretation - David O. Brink
13. Was Dworkin an Originalist? - Larry Alexander
14. The Moral Reading of Constitutions - Connie S. Rosati
15. Authority, Intention and Interpretation - Aditi Bagchi
16. Concern and Respect in Procedural Law - Hamish Stewart
1. A Hedgehog's Unity of Value - Joseph Raz
Part II: Political Values: Legitimacy, Authority, and Collective Responsibility
2. Political Resistance for Hedgehogs - Candice Delmas
3. Ronald Dworkin, State Consent and Progressive Cosmopolitanism - Thomas Christiano
4. To Fill or Not To Fill Individual Responsibility Gaps? - François Tanguay-Renaud
5. Inheritance and Hypothetical Insurance - Daniel Halliday
Part III: General Jurisprudence: Contesting the Unity of Law and Value
6. Putting Law in Its Place - Lawrence G. Sager
7. Dworkin and Unjust Law - David Dyzenhaus
8. The Grounds of Law - Luís Duarte d'Almeida
9. Immodesty in Dworkin's 'Third' Theory - Kenneth Einar Himma
10. Imperialism and Importance in Dworkin's Jurisprudence - Michael Giudice
11. A Theory of Legal Obligation - Christopher Essert
Part IV: Value in Law
12. Originalism and Constructive Interpretation - David O. Brink
13. Was Dworkin an Originalist? - Larry Alexander
14. The Moral Reading of Constitutions - Connie S. Rosati
15. Authority, Intention and Interpretation - Aditi Bagchi
16. Concern and Respect in Procedural Law - Hamish Stewart
